FANDOM


(All Character Articles Listed Here)
Line 20: Line 20:
 
=== The Majority of/Most/All Staff Articles Currently Listed Here ===
 
=== The Majority of/Most/All Staff Articles Currently Listed Here ===
 
{{S}}I understand that some of these articles have unique information, but most of that information can be found on Wikipedia. In addition to this, a lot of the pages for staff barely contribute anything of interest besides the role the member played during the series' being produced.
 
{{S}}I understand that some of these articles have unique information, but most of that information can be found on Wikipedia. In addition to this, a lot of the pages for staff barely contribute anything of interest besides the role the member played during the series' being produced.
  +
{{o}} Half and half. While I support the deletion of actors who have wikipedia pages, i believe staff should be kept. Yes, all of them. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|07:40,3/9/2019}} 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
   
 
=== All Character Articles Listed Here ===
 
=== All Character Articles Listed Here ===
 
{{S}}Every character article I have tagged is believed by myself to be too minor to have an article. Most of the characters appeared for a split-second in one or two episodes, or had fewer than 2 short lines of dialogue. With the exception of the [[Lilliputtian head knight]] and [[Lilliputtian pirate captain]], all other articles should be deleted.
 
{{S}}Every character article I have tagged is believed by myself to be too minor to have an article. Most of the characters appeared for a split-second in one or two episodes, or had fewer than 2 short lines of dialogue. With the exception of the [[Lilliputtian head knight]] and [[Lilliputtian pirate captain]], all other articles should be deleted.
+
{{o}}I don't thik so. Even if it's a very minor character you shouldn't delet it. It takes a while to make a page and you delet it in a second. This is just wrong.
+
{{o}} Hm, I don't agree on deleting all of them outright. Some, like the [[Principal of Glass Shard Beach High School]] I'd like to keep, since he's got a VA and... an arguably important role in what happens in the plot. On the other hand, [[Unnamed girl with freckles]] can be merged into one page of minor recurring characters... In this case, I think we'll need a section for each character to vote on. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|07:40,3/9/2019}} 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
 
I don't thik so. Even if it's a very minor character you shouldn't delet it. It takes a while to make a page and you delet it in a second. This is just wrong.
 
   
 
===Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain===
 
===Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain===
Line 32: Line 33:
 
From the article guidelines: "Every character that visually appears on the show is allowed to have a page, ''except ''for characters that only appear in a group '''and''' don't perform any unique individual actions." These characters appear visually in the show and, even though they are part of a group, they perform unique individual actions.
 
From the article guidelines: "Every character that visually appears on the show is allowed to have a page, ''except ''for characters that only appear in a group '''and''' don't perform any unique individual actions." These characters appear visually in the show and, even though they are part of a group, they perform unique individual actions.
 
Even if they had small roles, they're not just another Lilliputtian from the bunch. [[Franz]], [[Big Henry]] and [[Polly]] have their own pages too, and the latter two had very small roles. Should we delete them too? Or is it that the Head Knight and the Captain shouldn't get pages just because their names weren't given? [[User:Assistant Co captain Falcone|Assistant Co captain Falcone]] ([[User talk:Assistant Co captain Falcone|talk]]) 21:40, February 23, 2019 (UTC)
 
Even if they had small roles, they're not just another Lilliputtian from the bunch. [[Franz]], [[Big Henry]] and [[Polly]] have their own pages too, and the latter two had very small roles. Should we delete them too? Or is it that the Head Knight and the Captain shouldn't get pages just because their names weren't given? [[User:Assistant Co captain Falcone|Assistant Co captain Falcone]] ([[User talk:Assistant Co captain Falcone|talk]]) 21:40, February 23, 2019 (UTC)
  +
{{o}} {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|07:40,3/9/2019}} 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
   
 
== Categories ==
 
== Categories ==

Revision as of 07:40, March 9, 2019

 !
Shortcut:
GF:CFD

Use this page to discuss pages that have been labelled for deletion.
See archived discussions:

When discussing, please use the following templates:

15px-Symbol_support_vote.svg.png Support — {{S}}
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — {{O}}
15px-Symbol_neutral_vote.svg.png Neutral — {{N}}
15px-Pictogram_voting_comment.svg.png Comment — {{C}}

BE SURE TO SIGN YOUR NAMES WITH FOUR (4) TILDE: ~~~~

Pages

The Majority of/Most/All Staff Articles Currently Listed Here

15px-Symbol_support_vote.svg.png Support —I understand that some of these articles have unique information, but most of that information can be found on Wikipedia. In addition to this, a lot of the pages for staff barely contribute anything of interest besides the role the member played during the series' being produced.
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — Half and half. While I support the deletion of actors who have wikipedia pages, i believe staff should be kept. Yes, all of them. YazzyDream 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)

All Character Articles Listed Here

15px-Symbol_support_vote.svg.png Support —Every character article I have tagged is believed by myself to be too minor to have an article. Most of the characters appeared for a split-second in one or two episodes, or had fewer than 2 short lines of dialogue. With the exception of the Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain, all other articles should be deleted.
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — I don't thik so. Even if it's a very minor character you shouldn't delet it. It takes a while to make a page and you delet it in a second. This is just wrong.
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — Hm, I don't agree on deleting all of them outright. Some, like the Principal of Glass Shard Beach High School I'd like to keep, since he's got a VA and... an arguably important role in what happens in the plot. On the other hand, Unnamed girl with freckles can be merged into one page of minor recurring characters... In this case, I think we'll need a section for each character to vote on. YazzyDream 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)

Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain

15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — The Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain have been marked for deletion for the following reason: "Just because he is the leader doesn't justify a page". But they didn't get a page for being leaders of their holes, they got pages for having their own dialogue and a distinct participation from other Lilliputtians in the episode.

From the article guidelines: "Every character that visually appears on the show is allowed to have a page, except for characters that only appear in a group and don't perform any unique individual actions." These characters appear visually in the show and, even though they are part of a group, they perform unique individual actions. Even if they had small roles, they're not just another Lilliputtian from the bunch. Franz, Big Henry and Polly have their own pages too, and the latter two had very small roles. Should we delete them too? Or is it that the Head Knight and the Captain shouldn't get pages just because their names weren't given? Assistant Co captain Falcone (talk) 21:40, February 23, 2019 (UTC)

15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png OpposeYazzyDream 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)

Categories

Redirects

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.