FANDOM


m (Sister Mary Hilda Miley)
(The Majority of/Most/All Staff Articles Currently Listed Here)
 
(102 intermediate revisions by 24 users not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:
 
*[[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive3|December 15, 2014 - May 26, 2015]]
 
*[[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive3|December 15, 2014 - May 26, 2015]]
 
*[[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive4|May 26, 2015 - August 28, 2016]]
 
*[[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive4|May 26, 2015 - August 28, 2016]]
*[[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive5|August]]
+
*[[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive5|August 28, 2016 -]]
   
 
When discussing, please use the following templates:
 
When discussing, please use the following templates:
Line 14: Line 14:
 
{{N}} <nowiki>{{N}}</nowiki>
 
{{N}} <nowiki>{{N}}</nowiki>
 
{{C}} <nowiki>{{C}}</nowiki>
 
{{C}} <nowiki>{{C}}</nowiki>
<big>'''BE SURE TO SIGN YOUR NAMES WITH FOUR (4) TILDE: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki></big>
+
<big>'''BE SURE TO SIGN YOUR NAMES WITH FOUR (4) TILDE: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>'''</big>
 
}}
 
}}
   
 
==Pages==
 
==Pages==
  +
=== The Majority of/Most/All Staff Articles Currently Listed Here ===
  +
{{S}}I understand that some of these articles have unique information, but most of that information can be found on Wikipedia. In addition to this, a lot of the pages for staff barely contribute anything of interest besides the role the member played during the series' being produced.
  +
{{o}} Half and half. While I support the deletion of actors who have wikipedia pages, i believe staff should be kept. Yes, all of them. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|07:40,3/9/2019}} 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
  +
{{o}} basically what Yazzy said.
  +
{{N}} I think that we should keep the ones for main characters voice actors like Soos, Dipper, and Ford but ones like Melody aren’t really important. -eveglob
  +
[http://gravityfalls.wikia.com/wiki/User:ThePK http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/central/images/f/f1/Pineapple_u86.gif][[User:ThePK|<span style="color:#7a807f;">'''''The'''''</span> '''<span style="color:#ffc45e;">P</span><span style="color:#80d0ff;">K</span>''']]'''<sup><span style="color:#7a807f;">(</span>[[User_talk:ThePK|<font color="#ffc45e">Wall</font>]]<span style="color:#7a807f;">•</span>[[w:User:ThePK/Guestbook|<font color="#80d0ff">Guestbook</font>]]<span style="color:#7a807f;">)</span></sup> [http://steven-universe.wikia.com/wiki/User:ThePK http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/central/images/a/ae/Mudkip.png]'''
  +
08:26, April 29, 2019 (UTC)
  +
{{O}} [[List of Gravity Falls Staff]] just has their names. These individual articles have way more information (including credits for specific episodes). [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 19:19, July 12, 2019 (UTC)
  +
{{o}}I think that theory articles should not be deleted, since it still contributes to the show Gravity Falls. [[User:Snowyflakeajs|Snowyflakeajs]] ([[User talk:Snowyflakeajs|talk]]) 15:50, March 16, 2020 (UTC)Snowyflakeajs 
   
  +
=== All Character Articles Listed Here ===
  +
{{S}}Every character article I have tagged is believed by myself to be too minor to have an article. Most of the characters appeared for a split-second in one or two episodes, or had fewer than 2 short lines of dialogue. With the exception of the [[Lilliputtian head knight]] and [[Lilliputtian pirate captain]], all other articles should be deleted.
  +
{{o}}I don't thik so. Even if it's a very minor character you shouldn't delet it. It takes a while to make a page and you delet it in a second. This is just wrong.
  +
{{o}} Hm, I don't agree on deleting all of them outright. Some, like the [[Principal of Glass Shard Beach High School]] I'd like to keep, since he's got a VA and... an arguably important role in what happens in the plot. On the other hand, [[Unnamed girl with freckles]] can be merged into one page of minor recurring characters... In this case, I think we'll need a section for each character to vote on. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|07:40,3/9/2019}} 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
   
===[[Cheekums/Gallery]]===
+
===Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain===
{{S}} There are only five images. Not enough to constitute a gallery. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 03:09, November 1, 2015 (UTC)
 
{{O}} It maybe small, but that doesn't mean you should get rid of it. [[User:Sandgar|Sandgar]] ([[User talk:Sandgar|talk]]) 01:05, January 7, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{O}} It's actually six and that's enough images for a gallery, and also the artwork created by Alex is contained in it. If it were to have like 2-3 then maybe I'd say fine but nope this isn't the case. --[[User:Rachin123|Rai 水]] ([[User talk:Rachin123|talk]]) 00:19, January 11, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}} In the past we have deleted many galleries with more images than this one for being too small. Also, the production art should go on [[Little Dipper/Gallery]]. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 23:42, January 11, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}} Oh really? Which galleries? And how many images would you consider to have a gallery? --[[User:Rachin123|Rai 水]] ([[User talk:Rachin123|talk]]) 02:03, January 12, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}} There used to be a gallery for [[Big Gunz Laser Tag]]. It had six images, and was deleted for being too minor. Another one is [[Nearly Almost Dead But Not Quite!]] That had five images. And [[Project Mentem]]'s gallery had eight. There are plenty more, as can be seen [[Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archive4|here]].
 
   
I think I said this before, but to constitute a gallery, there should be at least nine good images that are all distinct from each other. This gallery only has five. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 18:49, January 16, 2016 (UTC)
 
   
{{N}} It is pretty small, but there is an image from production artwork.--[[User:Peacexfreedom|Peacexfreedom]] ([[User talk:Peacexfreedom|talk]]) 23:13, January 27, 2016 (UTC)
+
{{O}} The [[Lilliputtian head knight]] and [[Lilliputtian pirate captain]] have been marked for deletion for the following reason: "'''Just because he is the leader doesn't justify a page".''' But they didn't get a page for being leaders of their holes, they got pages for having their own dialogue and a distinct participation from other Lilliputtians in the episode.
+
From the article guidelines: "Every character that visually appears on the show is allowed to have a page, ''except ''for characters that only appear in a group '''and''' don't perform any unique individual actions." These characters appear visually in the show and, even though they are part of a group, they perform unique individual actions.
{{O}} Not enough pictures unfortunately but there is some production art as others have said. Maybe there is a way to salvage this, and add in some more pictures?. Liftboard Rider 09:20, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
+
Even if they had small roles, they're not just another Lilliputtian from the bunch. [[Franz]], [[Big Henry]] and [[Polly]] have their own pages too, and the latter two had very small roles. Should we delete them too? Or is it that the Head Knight and the Captain shouldn't get pages just because their names weren't given? [[User:Assistant Co captain Falcone|Assistant Co captain Falcone]] ([[User talk:Assistant Co captain Falcone|talk]]) 21:40, February 23, 2019 (UTC)
+
{{o}} {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|07:40,3/9/2019}}
:{{C}} How could we add in more pictures? These are the pictures that we got from the series. I don't see what value this gallery has; if it doesn't have enough pictures, it should be deleted. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 14:33, August 17, 2016 (UTC)
+
{{o}} No I think that he is important -eveglob
+
07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
===[[Footbot/Gallery]]===
 
{{S}} There are only six images, none of which are very distinct (they don't reveal much about the subject). [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 23:43, April 7, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{O}} I think it is fine to have them in a gallery so they don't crowd the main page [[User:Sandgar|Sandgar]], Leader of HTF Wiki 04:22, April 8, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{O}} I agree with Gage [[User:Madialiano|✿♥Madialiano♥✿]] ([[User talk:Madialiano|talk]]) 18:36, April 15, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{S}} Not enough pictures unfortunately. Liftboard Rider 09:20, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
===[[Lava Lamp Shaped Demon]]===
 
{{S}} At this point I think we should just delete this page on sight. I believe this is the third time this page has been created. This is way too minor, and it was only ever seen in the backround. It was never named, and there's no use in having a page for it. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 02:35, December 26, 2015 (UTC)
 
 
{{S}}  There is not enough information on the page.  However all the demons of Bill Cipher are important and should all get a page.  The page should be something along the lines of "Bill Cipher's Demons" and discuss each demon seperately.  Alone there isn't enough information for most demons to warrent a page, but they are important to the story and with all on one page there should be more than enough information to propperly make a page. [[User:Dcat682|Dcat682]] ([[User talk:Dcat682|talk]]) 02:49, December 26, 2015 (UTC)
 
 
{{O}} Even though we don't have a name for it, it is one of Bill's minions. Actually, if it were to be deleted, it would be the ''only'' minion without a page. Unless all of Bill's minions were to have a combined page. I'd be cool with that.[[User:Peacexfreedom|Peacexfreedom]] ([[User talk:Peacexfreedom|talk]]) 02:55, December 26, 2015 (UTC)
 
{{O}}^ [[User:Sandgar|Sandgar]], Normal Human 13:54, January 8, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}} --[[User:Rachin123|Rai 水]] ([[User talk:Rachin123|talk]]) 00:23, January 11, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}}This may be minor, but a lot of unnamed characters appear on the show, and many are less evident then this one.{{unsigned|Sandgar}}
 
{{O}} Eh, I think it should keep its own page, like Peace said, since the rest have their own. Also, we might see more of it next episode? [[User:Juan The American Brony|Juan The American Brony]] ([[User talk:Juan The American Brony|talk]]) 16:56, February 3, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{O}} [[User:Hero Fan|Hero Fan]] ([[User talk:Hero Fan|talk]]) 23:44, February 16, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}}Page full of speculation and a fan made title to boot. Besides the page was already deleted.--[[User:Topdarlingwh|Topdarlingwh]] ([[User talk:Topdarlingwh|talk]]) 00:07, February 28, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{n}} I like the idea of having a page for every one of the weird creatures Bill invited. It being the exception when they others have a page, is a little... eh. But it really depends on the information we can compile from it. If we can make a serviceable page with all its appearances and history, then I'd say keep it. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|01:36,8/12/2016}} 01:36, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{O}} I agree with the arguments for keeping it listed above, but it does need some work for sure. Liftboard Rider 09:15, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
<span style="color:rgb(0,0,0);font-size:11.9px;font-weight:normal;line-height:22px;">{{C}} I agree that we should either keep a page for lava lamp demon or create one for Bill's henchmaniacs as a group. Lava lamp demon not being mentioned in the series is exactly the reason why he should be mentioned somewhere in the wiki, because many people don't know about the existence of this rather curious character. In a very related issue, I created [[Unnamed lava lamp demon|another page]] for the same character (I didn't find his page, so I thought he didn't have one, sorry. This page's creator didn't make a good job creating links from related pages, I guess.) We should merge the pages, mine has more information and follows the article guidelines for characters, I think. [[User:Assistant Co captain Falcone|Assistant Co captain Falcone]] ([[User talk:Assistant Co captain Falcone|talk]]) 22:23, August 29, 2016 (UTC)</span>
 
 
===[[List of deaths]]===
 
{{S}} It just seems very random, like having a page for "list of criminals". This page is also redundant to the existing deceased category. It is sufficient to list the cause of death/whatever on each character's page. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 13:40, May 7, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{O}} [[User:ThatGuy30722|ThatGuy30722]] - '''I can hold 10 babies at once!''' 11:09, June 11, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{O}} [[User:Silvery2|The coolest guy EVA!]] - '''It works for PIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGS!''' 08:08, June 18, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{S}} [[User:Dr. Dementor|Dr. Dementor]] - We already have a page for deceased characters we dont need an extra list for it. 09:34, June 19, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{C}} @Dr. Dementor: Well, the category doesn't explain how they died and when, you'd have to go to the character's page for that. But this is easier, it's all in one place. [[User:ThatGuy30722|ThatGuy30722]] - '''I can hold 10 babies at once!''' 12:01, June 20, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{S}} One could find the exact same information just by typing "Category:Deceased." [[User:Lcclamerica|Lcclamerica]] ([[User talk:Lcclamerica|talk]]) 06:17, July 14, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{s}}{{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|01:36,8/12/2016}} 01:36, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
{{O}} Maybe just make sure all the information about how they died is already on the pages before deleting so no information gets lost. Though Looking at it, it does make for a handy reference page. Liftboard Rider 09:20, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
 
 
===[[Sister Mary Hilda Miley]]===
 
{{S}} Not related to the actual series; we'd have to make a page for every Cipher Hunt clue if we kept this. The information on this page is fine on the [[Cipher Hunt]] page. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 21:47, August 26, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{s}} {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|22:54,8/26/2016}} 22:54, August 26, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}} [[User:Geoff&#38;Courtneyfan|Geoff&#38;Courtneyfan Hey don&#39;t steal my food!]] ([[User talk:Geoff&#38;Courtneyfan|talk]]) 18:19, August 28, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{O}} the article is just too fun not to keep [http://gravityfalls.wikia.com/wiki/User:ThePK http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/central/images/f/f1/Pineapple_u86.gif][[User:ThePK|<span style="color:#7a807f;">'''''The'''''</span> '''<span style="color:#ffc45e;">P</span><span style="color:#80d0ff;">K</span>]]'''<sup><span style="color:#7a807f;">(</span>[[User_talk:ThePK|<font color="#ffc45e">Wall</font>]]<span style="color:#7a807f;">•</span>[[w:User:ThePK/Guestbook|<font color="#80d0ff">Guestbook</font>]]<span style="color:#7a807f;">)</span></sup> [http://steven-universe.wikia.com/wiki/User:ThePK http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/central/images/a/ae/Mudkip.png]
 
23:03, August 29, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
===[[Visions of Heartbreak Past]]===
 
{{S}}This is more an effect of a potion/power right? It should be part of the potion's page or something. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|10:14,8/15/2016}} 10:14, August 15, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}} Merge with potions page. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 14:37, August 17, 2016 (UTC)
 
 
===[[List of crossover characters]]===
 
{{s}} Something like this can be regulated to the individual games' pages. Not to mention these only mention [[Villains Unite!]] Why not just keep the information there? {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|04:45,8/26/2016}} 04:45, August 26, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{s}} Agreed with YazzyDream. [[User:Geoff&#38;Courtneyfan|Geoff&#38;Courtneyfan Hey don&#39;t steal my food!]] ([[User talk:Geoff&#38;Courtneyfan|talk]]) 20:04, August 26, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}}[[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 21:49, August 26, 2016 (UTC)
 
   
 
== Categories ==
 
== Categories ==
===[[:Category:Alternate time periods|Alternate Time Periods]]===
 
{{S}} Just seems very random to have around. Yes, these things are from alternate time periods... so what? Also, this category's existence leads to such confusions as what counts as an alternate time period; should [[Mrs. Pines (Stan's mother)]] and [[Filbrick Pines]] be in this category, or are they too close to the present? And [[Glass Shard Beach, New Jersey]] in all probability still exists, so why is it an alternate time period? And the same goes for [[Quentin Trembley]]. All in all, I don't see the purpose of this category, and it just makes things more confusing. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 19:18, August 19, 2016 (UTC)
 
===[[:Category:Gravity Falls|Gravity Falls]]===
 
{{S}} Duplicate of [[:Category: A to Z]]--[[User:Peacexfreedom|Peacexfreedom]] ([[User talk:Peacexfreedom|talk]]) 21:41, March 7, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}}[[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 01:46, March 8, 2016 (UTC)
 
   
===[[:Category:Species|Species]]===
+
==Redirects==
{{S}}We have a creature '''and''' character category to make a distinctive difference between them both. This just counter acts that...--[[User:Topdarlingwh|Topdarlingwh]] ([[User talk:Topdarlingwh|talk]]) 22:01, February 28, 2016 (UTC)
 
   
{{C}} "Creatures" are individual, well, creatures, whereas "species" are groups/types of creatures.[[User:Peacexfreedom|Peacexfreedom]] ([[User talk:Peacexfreedom|talk]]) 22:40, February 28, 2016 (UTC)
+
==Teenz Talk and other TV shows==
   
{{C}} If we could, I propose we change it so that Characters are any individual, while Creatures are the species (So, [[Mermando]] would be a Character and [[Merpeople]] would be Creatures), thus warranting the deletion of this category. It just makes sense with the infoboxes, as currently Mermando's infobox lists information that is already on the Merpeople page, when a character box could list things like age, other names, etc. Plus, for the purpose of the show and plot, Mermando is a character. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 23:13, February 28, 2016 (UTC)
+
{{O}} - I don't believe these should be deleted just yet. Not deleting them would make it:
{{C}} I'm not so sure on that one. I kinda like having the distinction (easily via category, I mean) between humans and creatures (humans being characters, as it is now). It's not that I don't like/mind calling the individual creatures "characters" but having a category that is just the creatures (individual ones, I mean) is nice for sorting--[[User:Peacexfreedom|Peacexfreedom]] ([[User talk:Peacexfreedom|talk]]) 23:34, February 28, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}}We have a category called "groups" as well...--[[User:Topdarlingwh|Topdarlingwh]] ([[User talk:Topdarlingwh|talk]]) 23:36, February 28, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}} Perhaps we could then change the character category's name to "humans"? The current name just causes confusion in my view. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 00:18, February 29, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}} Actually, I'd be okay with deleting the "Species" category (and making no additional changes) due to the existence of the "[[List of creatures]]" page (which seems to serve the same function).--[[User:Peacexfreedom|Peacexfreedom]] ([[User talk:Peacexfreedom|talk]]) 01:26, February 29, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}} On the deletion of this category, assuming nothing else will change. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 20:42, March 1, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{C}} I suggest we put Creatures under beings who are from a species while the actual group be under species. For example, We'd put Unicorns under species, while [[Celestabellebethabelle]] would be under creatures. As for the group thing, that could go for anything. Bands, Teams, etc. so it's not the same as species. --[[User:Rachin123|Rai 水]] ([[User talk:Rachin123|talk]]) 19:08, March 2, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{S}} Rachin123's idea. But will not cross out my previous support because if Rachin's idea cannot be enacted, I support the deletion of this page. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 19:29, August 19, 2016 (UTC)
 
   
===[[:Category:Zodiac carriers]]===
+
a.) easier to put <nowiki> [[Teenz Talk]] </nowiki> thingamajigs. (links)
{{S}} If it's just gonna be empty, it's useless. [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 23:42, May 9, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{Deleted}}
 
   
==Redirects==
+
b.) easier to find the page itself instead of adding redlinks and redirects. (i.e., it would be simpler just to keep the existing pages versus delete them and make all the redirects, then from there have all the preexisting links become redlinks)
===[[Mrs. Pines]]===
 
{{S}} [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 21:28, May 11, 2016 (UTC)
 
{{o}} redirects are exist also for people searching the wiki for information. {{User:YazzyDream/SigReal|02:04,8/1/2016}} 02:04, August 1, 2016 (UTC)
 
   
{{N}} Fair point, I am on the fence about this one, since it is for a character title that we would expect people to use.Liftboard Rider 09:24, August 12, 2016 (UTC)
+
Also, what if someone just wants to find a page singularly about what they are looking for versus a page with all the other links/articles/sections on it? That would make quite a bit more sense.
   
{{C}} When one types "Mrs. Pines" into the search bar, [[Mrs. Pines (disambiguation)]] comes up anyway, so I don't see what good this page does. And we don't have a redirect called "Mr. Pines", and we've gotten along fine without that. This page also prevents us from naming the page for Stan's mother "Mrs. Pines", giving it the awkward title, "[[Mrs. Pines (Stan's mother)]]". [[User:Mr B Natural|<font color="#660099" face="Curlz MT"><big><big><big>Mr B</big></big></big></font>]][[User Talk:Mr B Natural|<font color="green"><sup><sup>Knew <sub><sub>your</sub></sub><sup>father</sup> <sub>I</sub> <sub><sub><sub>did!</sub></sub></sub></sup></sup></font>]] 14:39, August 17, 2016 (UTC)
+
That's my argument. [[User:Enderfiretheanimusdragon|Enderfiretheanimusdragon]] ([[User talk:Enderfiretheanimusdragon|talk]]) 18:22, July 15, 2019 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 15:50, March 16, 2020

 !
Shortcut:
GF:CFD

Use this page to discuss pages that have been labelled for deletion.
See archived discussions:

When discussing, please use the following templates:

15px-Symbol_support_vote.svg.png Support — {{S}}
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — {{O}}
15px-Symbol_neutral_vote.svg.png Neutral — {{N}}
15px-Pictogram_voting_comment.svg.png Comment — {{C}}

BE SURE TO SIGN YOUR NAMES WITH FOUR (4) TILDE: ~~~~

PagesEdit

The Majority of/Most/All Staff Articles Currently Listed Here Edit

15px-Symbol_support_vote.svg.png Support —I understand that some of these articles have unique information, but most of that information can be found on Wikipedia. In addition to this, a lot of the pages for staff barely contribute anything of interest besides the role the member played during the series' being produced.
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — Half and half. While I support the deletion of actors who have wikipedia pages, i believe staff should be kept. Yes, all of them. YazzyDream 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — basically what Yazzy said.
15px-Symbol_neutral_vote.svg.png Neutral — I think that we should keep the ones for main characters voice actors like Soos, Dipper, and Ford but ones like Melody aren’t really important. -eveglob

Pineapple_u86.gifThe PK(WallGuestbook) Mudkip.png 08:26, April 29, 2019 (UTC)

15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png OpposeList of Gravity Falls Staff just has their names. These individual articles have way more information (including credits for specific episodes). Mr BKnew yourfather I did! 19:19, July 12, 2019 (UTC)
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — I think that theory articles should not be deleted, since it still contributes to the show Gravity Falls. Snowyflakeajs (talk) 15:50, March 16, 2020 (UTC)Snowyflakeajs 

All Character Articles Listed Here Edit

15px-Symbol_support_vote.svg.png Support —Every character article I have tagged is believed by myself to be too minor to have an article. Most of the characters appeared for a split-second in one or two episodes, or had fewer than 2 short lines of dialogue. With the exception of the Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain, all other articles should be deleted.
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — I don't thik so. Even if it's a very minor character you shouldn't delet it. It takes a while to make a page and you delet it in a second. This is just wrong.
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — Hm, I don't agree on deleting all of them outright. Some, like the Principal of Glass Shard Beach High School I'd like to keep, since he's got a VA and... an arguably important role in what happens in the plot. On the other hand, Unnamed girl with freckles can be merged into one page of minor recurring characters... In this case, I think we'll need a section for each character to vote on. YazzyDream 07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)

Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captainEdit

15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — The Lilliputtian head knight and Lilliputtian pirate captain have been marked for deletion for the following reason: "Just because he is the leader doesn't justify a page". But they didn't get a page for being leaders of their holes, they got pages for having their own dialogue and a distinct participation from other Lilliputtians in the episode.

From the article guidelines: "Every character that visually appears on the show is allowed to have a page, except for characters that only appear in a group and don't perform any unique individual actions." These characters appear visually in the show and, even though they are part of a group, they perform unique individual actions. Even if they had small roles, they're not just another Lilliputtian from the bunch. Franz, Big Henry and Polly have their own pages too, and the latter two had very small roles. Should we delete them too? Or is it that the Head Knight and the Captain shouldn't get pages just because their names weren't given? Assistant Co captain Falcone (talk) 21:40, February 23, 2019 (UTC)

15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png OpposeYazzyDream
15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — No I think that he is important -eveglob

07:40, March 9, 2019 (UTC)

Categories Edit

RedirectsEdit

Teenz Talk and other TV showsEdit

15px-Symbol_oppose_vote.svg.png Oppose — - I don't believe these should be deleted just yet. Not deleting them would make it:

a.) easier to put [[Teenz Talk]] thingamajigs. (links)

b.) easier to find the page itself instead of adding redlinks and redirects. (i.e., it would be simpler just to keep the existing pages versus delete them and make all the redirects, then from there have all the preexisting links become redlinks)

Also, what if someone just wants to find a page singularly about what they are looking for versus a page with all the other links/articles/sections on it? That would make quite a bit more sense.

That's my argument. Enderfiretheanimusdragon (talk) 18:22, July 15, 2019 (UTC)

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.