Talk: Candidates for deletion

Revision as of 02:01, 4 October 2017

!

Shortcut: GF:CFD

Use this page to discuss pages that have been labelled for deletion.
See archived discussions:

When discussing, please use the following templates:

Support — {{S}}

Oppose — {{O}}

Neutral — {{N}}

Comment — {{C}}

BE SURE TO SIGN YOUR NAMES WITH FOUR (4) TILDE: ~~~~

Pages

Dipper and Mabel and the Curse of the Time Pirates' Treasure!: Select Your Own Choose-Venture/Transcript

Support — This is the only book for which we have a transcript, and the transcript format doesn't work very well for it, and this creates some inconsistencies because we don't have transcripts for any other books. Transcripts are meant for episodes, as the transcript box template says. Besides, a transcript of a book is sorta like a reproduction of the book, which is a copyright infringement. Mr B^{^{Knew _{_your}^father _I _{_{_did!}}}} 13:29, April 8, 2017 (UTC)

Support — It's inappropriate for a book to have a public transcript, and it is more possible to cause copyright problem than the series itself. - Oganesson (talk) 03:46, August 25, 2017 (UTC)

Ink Blot

Support — This is just one page in a book. If we're looking for a place to put the image, we can just put it on the Dipper and Mabel's Guide to Nonstop Fun page or its gallery. There are plenty of significant things in the various books (heck, there's a similar ink blot in Journal 3), and making pages for all of them would be a huge pain, and the pages would be mostly empty. Mr B^{^{Knew _{_your}^father _I _{_{_did!}}}} 04:41, October 1, 2017 (UTC)

Support — It's just a page of the book. I agree with Mr B Natural Diep Vuong (talk) 05:13, October 1, 2017 (UTC)

The Ultimate Crossover! Charity Drawathon

Support — Not at all related to Gravity Falls. Mr B^{^{Knew _{_your}^father _I _{_{_did!}}}} 18:57, August 24, 2017 (UTC)

Comment — It's not entirely related to Gravity Falls. Alex and his friends origanized this themselves. And none of the drawings in this stream is canon. It's just my thought Diep Vuong (talk) 02:47, August 25, 2017 (UTC)

Oppose — (Prefer not to delete, but I will respect the final decision) It was an event Alex Hirsch participated, and some of the content is related to Gravity Falls. I think this event is like Cipher Hunt, though it's not so canon, it's something happened in 2017, Gravity Falls-related. The purpose of this article is to be the place to place the video I uploaded, because it's not directly related to the series. It seems like there was no similar article like this before in this wiki, yet, it can be the first example of its kind! - Oganesson (talk) 03:31, August 25, 2017 (UTC)

Comment — Needing a place to put a video is no reason to have a page on this wiki. There are several better-suited places to put the video, YouTube coming to mind. And Hirsch seems to be doing a lot of these charity things, and it would be hard to keep up after awhile, especially since there's no reason for these charities to necessarily be related to Gravity Falls, unlike, say, a Gravity Falls episode, which is guaranteed to be related to Gravity Falls. What I'm saying is it would be hard to make a page for all for all of these charity things and even harder to determine whether each charity thing is related enough to Gravity Falls. Since it's not affiliated with Disney and doesn't directly relate to the series, it's essentially fan-art. Mr B^{^{Knew _{_your}^father _I _{_{_did!}}}} 02:01, October 4, 2017 (UTC)

Unnamed blonde hair man in pink

Oppose — He is a character who is seen on multiple occasions separate from other characters. If we deleted this page, the information on which episodes he is seen in would be totally lost. In short, this is a character page with unique information pertinent to the show and its environment. Mr B^{^{Knew _{_your}^father _I _{_{_did!}}}} 00:15, August 7, 2017 (UTC)

Unnamed man in black

Oppose — Same as reasons for "Unnamed blonde hair man in pink" Mr B^{^{Knew _{_your}^father _I _{_{_did!}}}} 00:15, August 7, 2017 (UTC)

Unnamed man in white with a beard