In the 1960s, Caryn lived in Glass Shard Beach, New Jersey, where she worked as a phone psychic, a vocation greatly aided by her pathological need to lie.
Caryn makes several appearances in Stan's flashbacks throughout "A Tale of Two Stans." She is seen working as a phone psychic and meeting with the Pines twins' principal about her sons' futures, during which she expresses concern for their "free spirit", Stanley. She also asks what is happening when Filbrick kicks Stanley out of the house.
She wears a red, sleeveless dress, white heels, golden bangles on her wrists and large golden hoop earrings. She has long nails, dark red lipstick and purple eye shadow. She wears a large part of her hair up in a partial beehive, leaving the rest of it loose.
- 212. "A Tale of Two Stans" (flashback)