Just putting this out there ~
The very end combined code translates to a short poem, possibly referring to most of the members:
GIDEON’S TANTRUMS, MISSPELLED TATTOOS, SHANDRA’S REJECTIONS, SOCIETY’S VIEWS, A FEAR OF WITCHES, A LIFE OF REGRET, THESE ARE THE THINGS THAT THEY TRY TO FORGET.
The tantrums are obviously referring to Bud, the tattoos to Tad, the rejections to Toby, the views to the Woodpecker guy, the fear probably to Sprott and the regretful life is apparently to McGucket.
This has already be figured out, probably, but I just wanted to make an account for it.