Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5711690-20140808181814

Okay, so I am hearing a lot a theories about Old Man McGucket of being the writer of all the books because people say that he used to have 6 fingers (on the book cover there is a hand with 6 fingers) and Bill was chasing him and cut his finger off and thats why he had bandages on his hand with only five fingers but the only thing that i dont get is that on his other hand he has 5 fingers but, his finger didnt get cut off on that hand. I really dont get it. Does anyone believe that theory? Also, does anyone believe the Lebam theory cause i just think that one was a little over board. Who knows? Anything can happen in Gravity Falls.  