Thread:Icehard712/@comment-7292165-20141229065533/@comment-5475153-20141229070746

Dipper's and Soos' stories can be assumed to be made up. Mabel's is the only canonical "story" in that episode, simply due to the fact that it was explicitly stated to be so: "Mabel, we already know that story! We just lived through it!"

- Dipper Pines