User blog:CaveJohnson/More on Book 1

Ok so I have a little more to talk about Book 1 so I was thinking whoever has Book 1 has to be amongst the symbols in the theme some of this is rehash from my previous blog

Pine Tree = Dipper No that's just silly

Shooting Star = Mabel Same deal

Star thing = Gideon Like I said in my previous blog no he has Book 2

Stitched Heart = Robbie Still possible but it seems to me he doesn't know enough to be the owner

Ice Pack = Wendy Like I said my sister believes this but I myself find it unlikely I don't really believe Wendy knows anything

Question Mark = Soos he does seem to know things so I think this is slighly possible

Shades = Blubs? Still not really sure on who this is some people say it's the shades of Young Stan but personally I believe it's Blubs/Durland and well I believe it's slighly possible they could've just taken it and gave it to that guy seen in Irrational Treasure but if that was the case I don't see the point in there being another book

Six Fingers = McGucket Due to that leaked picture (sorry for spoils if you haven't seen it) I believe McGucket is undoubtedly the writer of at least one of the books so Six Fingers most likely represents him But I don't know why he would've kept one so I believe it's unlikely he has it

Fex Symbol = Grunkle Stan as I said before this seems to be the fan favorite theory but I believe it's too obvious     so no I don't believe it's Grunkle Stan

Llama = ??? Ok so nobody really knows who this Llama person is there have been numerous thoughts on it

Llamas in general could be Llamas are frequently mentioned once by Larry and then I think again by the manotaurs? i'm not sure

A singular Llama character could also be Mabel yeah but she's Shooting Star

But then I got to thinking Llamas are said to be the greatest warriors so what if the Llama doesn't necessarily represent an actual llama so much as the greatest warrior of Gravity Falls

and I can think of nobody more qualified for that then Manly Dan

Now see you guys probably think i'm crazy What? I thought this was about who has Book 1 Manly Dan doesn't hit me as the type to read and that's true he doesn't me either but this is Gravity Falls were talking about

Did Norman hit you as the type to secretly be a bunch of gnomes?

No I don't think it did anybody so yes I believe Manly Dan of all people is in Possession of Book 1

and there is some basis for this as well

1 he works in the forest

The fact that he's a lumberjack makes it highly likely he could've very easily stumbled across Book 1 like Dipper did Book 3 inside a metal tree while cutting them down

2 His freakish strength

Perhaps Manly Dan was not always the ridiculous cartoony strongman we see today perhaps his strength was granted by some sort of spell he aquired from Book 1

Anyway I had another basis for it but I sorta forgot lol

If I remember I might add it in later

Anyway like before this is a loose theory probably nobody else will buy it but please tell me what you think.