User blog comment:Brett307/"Little Gift Shop of Horrors" Continuity?/@comment-25246269-20141012012334

With the key for the ending crytogram being "noncanon" I think this episode is noncanon. I mean like you said, Stan says that at the beginning of the "Abaconings" story that it's not true. So I think we should forget that this episode even happened.

Bottomliss Pit confused me too. I think that Stan, Soos, Dipper, & Mabel probably did go down the Bottomless Pit, but I'm unsure about how canon the stories they all told are. I think the "Trooth-Ache" story was real, and all the rest are noncanon though.