Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25548156-20130814194325/@comment-24616208-20140211003826

RockSunner wrote:

Olssonk wrote: 1.That's easy. This was a scene we didn't see. Possible, but Mabel's motivation to do that scene is weak. She promised only one more date. Why let Gideon drag her around somewhere in town in between? Doesn't that count as another date?

2. Gideon has a mom who could have left it around. Seriously? All she can do is "just keep vacuuming."

3. Dipper probably said where he was going when he left so that everyone knew when he would be back. He might have told someone, but Mabel's conversation with Wendy suggests she's clueless and not expecting to have to rescue Dipper.

"I don't know what's wrong with me. I thought everything was back to normal, but I still feel all gross... Maybe letting Dipper do it for me was a mistake. Gideon deserves an honest break up."

Not "I recognize that address Dipper gave us. It's Gideon's warehouse! He may be in danger, so I'd better go help him."

But I still like your theory. If you'd like to see the theory built up into a story, check out "The Life of Lebam" on fanfiction.net. I got about 5 lines into that story and couldn't go any longer. Also, how do you break up my quote into different lines?