Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-8161155-20140910013046/@comment-25368157-20140913203652

interesting theory, it would explain a lot really, but, here are some points to take into consideration:

1. when bill first meets the twins and soos, he greets them as "Shooting star, pine tree and question mark" yet when he meets gideon he doesnt call him the star.

2. based on what gideon said when he called bill ("We'll see what my new minion has to say about that") it is suggested that the jornal doesnt really have enough info on what bill really is, usually these rituals to call a higher power to become a minion are about demons and other dark evil creatures so it would make sense that bill makes a lot of deals (demons tend to make deals with humans in exchange for their souls)

3. if all the signs on the wheel are bill then doesnt that mean if the stan twin theory is true, it's already too late since stanley is either dead or in another universe/dimention? (how else would we explain the sign on the fez and the glasses if they were all people)

i will admit this is a truely interesting theory, if anything, writing this got me thinking what if to truely contain Bill you need all the people/places/things on the wheel? something idk, but truely interesting.