Thread:EvergreenFir/@comment-14814786-20130818170052

Today, I made an edit on the page for Book 1. In it, I removed sections that covered the 'Hiding Places' page from Book 2; obviously, that didn't belong on the page for Book 1. I also removed a mention of the symbol substituion cryptogram on Book 3's Portal Schematic page, again, didn't belong there. Lastly, I spiffed up the opening description and added the fact that the book is thicker than it's succesors to the appearance.

However, I soon found my changes to be reverted by the user Bill Cipher. I messaged him about what I assumed was his misconception: that the book shown in the 'flashback' sequence from Gideon Rises was Book 1. It came off as a bit uppity, so I immediately added a second message apologizing if it came off as such and explaining my reasoning.

If you won't take my word here for it, you can check out The thread on Bill's wall..

I put the page back to how I'd changed it, assuming it wouldn't be an issue having explained myself. Then Bill changed it back again. Indignantly and rather rudely stating there was nothing wrong with the page. I once again apologized if I had sounded rude, but urged him to actually read my explanation and look at the links therein.

I changed it again, he changed it back.

He replied to my last message by once again insisting there was nothing wrong with the page. I once again informed him that there was info on pages from the other books that shouldn't be on there on the page, this time making sure to explain ALL the things I removed.

No response as of yet, but the page has been changed again, although oddly not by Bill, but rather by a user by the name of DamideterJR. If there's something I'm not getting here let me know, but if I'm in the right, I could use some help here. If you want to see the version of the page I was posting, here's the source in the format for the editor:

1 is a cryptic journal owned by Stan Pines, the first of a series including 2 (previously owned by Gideon Gleeful) and 3 (previously owned by Dipper Pines), that contain knowledge on a wide variety of supernatural topics. It's writer is unknown.

History
The book first appeared in "Gideon Rises." Showing up in Gideon's imaginings of bringing the books together. It's first actual appearance comes later in the episode, when Stan took it off the shelf in the desk attached to the controls for the portal in his secret underground laboratory and used it, along with Books 2 and 3, to complete the portal's schematic.

Pages

 * Maze pageBook_1_Schematic_Page.png

Appearance


Journal #1 is outwardly burgundy and has various rips and tears, most noticeably a huge piece missing in the upper right hand corner of its cover. It has two gold lines on its spine and its three remaining cover-corners are gold as well. In the center of the cover there is a gold hand with six fingers, along with the number 1 written inside. Its pages are seemingly worn and hold various page markers, similar to books 2 and 3. It also appears to be the thickest of the books, possibly because it's author hadn't been planning to split it into multiple volumes until later.

Trivia

 * This book is the most damaged of all three books.


 * It was said to be buried near the Mystery Shack, so how it ended up in Stan's possession is unknown.

Gallery
Thank you for your time

-Lee 