Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27738735-20151013142838/@comment-25231652-20151014142334

RidleyKraid187 wrote:

~Boggy B~ wrote:

Mattgamer03 wrote: I really doubt Mabel's dead Actually, I saw the preview for the next episode just now, it kind of supports my theory that Mabel is dead. But we'll see, she could've just been in some sort of comatose state, if for some reason Bill decided to keep her alive. (Maybe to torture her?) I could see Mabel being kept alive as per Gideon's request. remember, Gideon is obsessed with Mabel, and unless just having her corpse as his own were good enough (ew...), he'd wanna keep Mabel alive. That's actually quite possible, but even if that was the case, Bill Cipher would inevitably betray Gideon after the latter fulfills his end of the bargain, and might either betray Gideon by killing Mabel or doing something to Gideon himself, then killing Mabel for the hell of it. But this could just be over-speculation, so it'd be fair enough to say there's a 50/50 chance that Bill killed Mabel, though I'd personally like to believe that he did. (No, I don't hate Mabel.)