User blog comment:PurplePenguin/The Grunkle Stan Mystery/@comment-67.54.166.74-20130519022441

2

I know it's been a while since I last commented, but I'm back, so here goes. I'm having a hard time understanding this whole thing, too, but I'll try my best.

So, first of all, oh my goodness, I think ROBBIE has book one. Dipper has book three and Gideon has book two, and remember Robbie has recently been shown with a song that hypnotized Wendy. But something doesn't seem right about it. I think that Stan is the author because of all the secrets around his Mystery Shack, and the fact that he has even MORE secrets, but I'm not sure. It's obviously not any of the kids in the book, because the third book's first entry read "I can't believe it's been six years since I started uncovering the strange happenings in Gravity Falls, Oregon". So it's an adult in the show, if not someone we haven't yet met. It's easy to see that Stan is one of the top suspects of writing them, but something about how it's written is different from Stan. I think something made him go grouchy, if he DID write the books. But it could also be Old Man McGucket, though that's not very likely. And it could be Toby Determined, or pretty much any other adult on the show. But the author did know a "he" that couldn't be trusted with the books, and some think the "he" is Stan and the author is someone else. If the "he" really IS Stan, that would stink because then the author could really be any adult. Except Lazy Susan, who's shown a liking for him. The author could also be one of the teenagers, like Robbie or Wendy, and they would have been around Mabel and Dipper's age when they wrote the books, but, as far as I know, none of them seem to know any untrustworthy "he"s other than Stan and Robbie. The author could be Wendy, and the "he" Robbie, and Robbie just hypnotized Wendy into forgetting that, but then Robbie wouldn't have said "Hope this works" before putting the DVD in because he would've known it worked, and it's most likely none of the other teens on the show. So the author's an adult who knows a "he". I think it's Stan and Gideon's the "he", but then how would Robbie have gotten ahold of a book if Stan doesn't like him so much? Maybe Robbie STOLE the book, and that's why Stan doesn't  like him.