Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25548156-20130814194325/@comment-25094659-20141117022133

I do not have time to read this whole thing, it's extremely long, but here's a summary of what we know:

The Pine Tree is Dipper, The Shooting Star is Mabel, and the Question Mark is Soos. We know this thanks to Bill.

Speculation can bring us someways as well. The only person so far we can associate with with the arm is Stanford Pines. The Pentagram is only associated with Gideon so far. The Heart is only seen on Robbie, and in a store, but we can safely assume it means Robbie :P

It gets hard when we come to the Ice, Llama, Six-fingered hand, and Glasses. There's too much speculation, and not enough proof. We can assume the hand it either The author or the Journals but that's about it. The other's are too vague so far, but I'll list the suspects

Ice: Wendy, Supernatural elements. This one doesn't have much, but it's extremely vague.

Llama: Pacifica, Manly Dan, Lebam, Narutal elements.

Glasses: Stanley, McGucket. Again, not much, but a little vague. We need more information.