Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25548156-20130814194325/@comment-4854965-20150209011404

Bennett535 wrote: These are what they are: (I don't  Ice bag is Wendy (she is shown around ice a lot) Crab claw thingamajig is Stan (his fez has the same symbol)

Tree is Dipper (his hat has the  THINK they are, I KNOW they are)

? is Soos (his shirt has a ? on it)

same pattern)

Star is Gideon (the tent of telepathy has the same star above it)

Hand is Old Man McGucket (the journals have the same hand)

/|\ Remember in the Blindeye episode when McGucket states that 'he worked with someone else'? Well, who I believe to be that someone else is already IN the wheel, so I'm saying that it's McGucket.

Llama is PACIFICA (she has a LLAMA SHIRT!!!)

/|\ Okay, now you all can stop fighting over who the llama is.

Shooting star is Mabel (she has a shooting star shirt)

Heart is Robbie (his jacket has the same design)

And the glasses are Stanley. (his glasses are the same)

/|\ If you don't know who Stanley is, look up "stanley pines gravity falls theory".

There you have it. First off, you can't say you "know" something (like this) without sufficient evidence.

Technically, the only ones we know to be true are Dipper, Mabel and Soos (as Bill called them by their respective icons in Dreamscaperers). For Robbie, Gideon, and Stan, their icons being the heart, the star, and the pac-man esque symbol, respetively, makes the most logical sense. The others are merely the "most likely".

You cannot definitively say the glasses are Stanley as that is a theory, and therefore cannot be included in such a bold statement as "I know".

The hand is most likely the author, as he is the only one we know that has six fingers (confirmed in show), and that appears on all three books. If you were thinking McGucket because of the "leaked" picture of him "writing the journals", that is officially (by Alex Hirsch) confirmed to be fake. He does not, and possibly never has had, six fingers on either hand.