Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25548156-20130814194325/@comment-24616208-20140209134910

RockSunner wrote: Then it's only fair to examine the "holes" in "The Hand the Rocks the Mabel" without a double.

1) When did Gideon have the chance to be seen with Mabel when she was wearing a plain sweater? The only two sweaters she wore around him at that point were the llama hair and the cat-face sweaters.

2) What was a plain sweater doing on a crate in his warehouse? If it was a gift for Mabel or from Mabel it wouldn't have been left around so casually. It's nothing like what he wears and it has no Gideon logo, so it's not just a piece of his merchandise.

3) How did Mabel know where to go to rescue Dipper? When she wanted to break up with Gideon she might have assumed he would be at home around 7:00pm, not at his warehouse. Someone may have communicated with her. 1.That's easy. This was a scene we didn't see.

2. Gideon has a mom who could have left it around.

3. Dipper probably said where he was going when he left so that everyone knew when he would be back.

But I still like your theory.