Thread:Topdarlingwh/@comment-26877689-20150811040613

Out of Intrest why is the song Big John not as valid for a source as John Henry? If anything the character seems to be based on a combination of the two, having both big and Henry. If it is because it is seen as speculation isn't saying hes inspired by John Henry also speculation? Sorry if this came across as rude I'm just a little confused as to why noting another reasonably well supported possibilty for his origin not allowed. 