User blog:CaveJohnson/Book 1 Theories

Ok so i've been making a lot of blogs about theories lately

Today I will be theorizing on the owner of Book 1 Here are all of the people I think are a possibility

Grunkle Stan/Old Man McGucket Ok so many people seem to accept the owner of Book 1 as Grunkle Stan or Old Man McGucket as I recently said on chat I doubt these two are the owners

I think that Grunkle Stan and Old Man McGucket collabratively wrote the 3 Books (since there are three maybe with someone else)

And since Book 3 Stated he had to hide this before HE finds it I believe that all 3 Books were hidden which makes me think someone else simply stumbled across Book 1 or HE found it and this has yet to be revealed

Gideon Some people believe Gideon simply has Book 1 and he has yet to show it but I find I find this extremely unlikely and if this is the case I don't even see the point in having 3 Books

Robbie Ok I feel like this is unlikely since my whole basis for this is he wrote the CD and figured out how to do so from the book but he claims he did not write it

Bill I think this is a possibility perhaps he is the HE spoken of in Book 3 and he actually managed to find

Book 1 and is still in search of the others perhaps Gideon and Bill's deal in Dreamscaperers

is he will do as he asks if he gets Book 2 in return

Wendy A friend of mine seems to think it's possible Wendy found Book 1

I don't really see any basis for this at all but I can't write it off completely

Anywho personally I think the most likely of these is Bill but it's probably someone else completely

Tell me which you think is the most likely