User blog:JosephHawk/Theory

Conspiracy Time!

The goat that keeps appearing in the Mystery Shack is...

Bill Cipher!!

When he possesses Dipper's body, look at his eyes.

The goat has the same eyes. The theory is this: Maybe Bill possessed the goat to keep an eye on the Pines twins before they even knew who he was. It would explain the last picture, because we know Bill wants the journal.

Like he said “I’m always watching.”

Thoughts?