User blog comment:DonyarktheKungFuMinion/Old Man McGucket: Crazy or Smart?/@comment-5184781-20130721222942

This may not be true, but I have a theory, in the picture of McGucket writing 2, or 3, or 1, he has six fingers, but when you see him oterwise, he has five fingers. In the page about Bill Cipher in 3, McGucket says stuff like "Bills a true gentleman" then says "Can't be..." and ends with "Do not spawn at all costs", not to mention the red stuff (pretty sure it's blood) on his page in 3, could it be that something might have happened with McGucket and Bill? Is that the reason there os a bandage on McGucket's hand? Did Bill get into McGucket's mind and have him cut off his finger while writing about bill and he noticed after the blood got all over the page?

That my friends, is my theory.