User blog:Imaguy1337/Who Owns Book 1?

So, in my first theory blog I will talk about... You guessed it, Book 1. Who isn't talking about it? so, let's run through some characters.

Dipper- No, just no.

Mabel- Wouldn't make any sense, Mabel would give it to Dipper. She wouldn't hide it, and I doubt she cold find it.

Soos- He is the only non-antagonist besides Dipper and Mabel to have realized the paranormal happenings on his own. However, his silly personality and fact he rarely goes in the woods make it unlikely.

Gideon- Probably not, as he has 2. If he had 1, he wouldn't know that there was a 3 necessarily, and he probably wouldn't show as much interest in Dipper having a book in Little Dipper.

Bill- Could quite likely be the he referenced in the books, and seems to have found the book fairly easily. He also flashed a picture of 3 during him saying he knows a lot of things. Also, his deal with Gideon could have been for Gideon to give him 2. I find this very likely. However, he flashed 3 in stead of one, which if he had 1 in possession he would have most likely flashed it.

Grunkle Stan- Very likely. When remembering Stan, Bill's eye widens. Stan is not what he seems is a cryptogram in the theme song. Stan definitely has a secret... 1 could be what's behind the vending machine. But is that that he has 1? Or something else?

Wendy- Goes in to the forest often, making finding likely. However, her denial of there being ghosts is Dusk to Dawn makes it unlikely.

Robbie- Although he had the CD and goes in the forest often, the fact he denies ghosts in Dusk 2 Dawn, that he was confused seeing Rumble and his lack of knowledge of the CD

Old Man McGucket- The leaked photo from Season 2 episode 3 shows him writing, which could imply he wrote the books, but his silliness and seeming lack of knowledge makes it unlikely. It could be that he was writing a extra caption in 1, like how Dipper did in 3.

Manly Dan- If it was hidden like 3, he would have a high chance of finding it. However, his lack of knowledge makes it unlikely. But his strength could have came from book one... But the Cordurary Brothers seem strong, which would mean it is probably just natural, Inherited strength.

Overall, I feel Bill, Stan and Old Man McGucket seem most likely.