Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-12265996-20141231184119/@comment-25953282-20150108202746

MinecraftPercabeth wrote:

1) I would say no, since, as you pointed out, he made the Gobblewonker by himself in his bad state of mind

2) It's tru that don't yet know what he knows, but we only know that he knows something. It's a guess that it has to do with the portal, but only a guess as there isn't a whole lot of evidence. On the other hand, what else is there to know? :P

2b) I've seen that as well, but it's purely imaginative. My first question was, "If you only erased Soos' mind (as it was kept in there as if it was the only one he used) why write the name? The Blindeye wrote names because they had a library of names" Either way, it's only a head-canon, and possible, but, at this point, unlikely.

3) If he seems like an idiot, he won't be a suspect. David once acted like a madman so as not to be caught or something  (I don't rememebr the story well) and in court cases you can plead insanity. Soos definatley isn't insane, but by acting stupid he might distract attnetion away from himself. Of course it's only an idea, and may be contributed to cartoon world discontinuity or lack of critical thinking in certain areas.

4) Is there any clues for this "theory", or is it just a passing thought? I don't like people coming up with ideas and taking the word "theory" on it. If there isn't much supporting evidence, or it's just a random idea you have, it should be a hypothesis.

First off, I apologize for taking so long to reply, a couple of days ago I got sick and couldn`t make it to the computer.

Now on with the discussion.

2) Yeah, I don`t see what else he could possibly be hiding besides some information on Stan`s past or the portal. Although Mr. Hirsch can be unpredictable xD

2b) Exactly what I thought, not to mention, his name written there just seems very convenient and the whole hiding place`s just a dumb move on behalf of Stan. This headcanon is very unlikely to happen.

3) I agree, couldn`t have said it better myself.

4) I wouldn`t exactly count this as a theory as there`s little evidance to support it and the person who wrote it claims it`s a theory although it seems more like a possibility than anything else. You can read it here